1.2 A Concrete Example - Class 8 - Poorvi (New)

Author: Not mentioned

Textbook: Poorvi

Genre: Poetry

Summary

The poem A Concrete Example describes the speaker’s observations of their neighbor Mrs. Jones’ stone-covered garden. Mrs. Jones has created a structured and decorative space with a path, lily pond, rockery, and sundial. However, the speaker is amused by her habit of planting tiny plants between the stones with precise care, which seems excessive and unnecessary. The poem contrasts natural growth with artificial beautification, offering subtle humor and critique of those who value control over nature. It highlights the irony of tending to lifeless stones with such seriousness, possibly commenting on modern human behavior and misplaced priorities. The tone is light-hearted yet reflective, making the reader question the meaning of real beauty and effort.

Character Sketch

Mrs. Jones

• A meticulous and somewhat eccentric gardener

• Values decoration, order, and structured beauty

• Enjoys placing tiny plants between stones

• Represents people who focus more on appearance than natural beauty

• Possibly symbolic of society's obsession with perfection

Themes

Literary Devices

Title Justification

The title A Concrete Example plays on the word “concrete,” both literally referring to the stone-filled garden and metaphorically to an example of human obsession with order and beauty. It hints at the poem’s theme—where a physical space becomes a symbol of deeper societal behavior. The title is apt because it represents both the literal setting and the broader commentary the poet makes about human tendencies.

One-Mark Questions

1. Why does the poet find Mrs. Jones’ gardening habits amusing? The poet finds it amusing that Mrs. Jones spends so much effort placing tiny plants between lifeless stones. The plants are so small that she plants them with a pin, which seems overly meticulous. This creates a humorous and ironic image.
   

2. What does the garden in the poem mainly consist of? The garden mainly consists of stones, a crazy path, a lily pond, and a rockery. There is also a sundial that Mrs. Jones finds attractive. These elements show her preference for structure over greenery.
   

3. How does the poet describe Mrs. Jones’ personality through the poem? Mrs. Jones appears detail-oriented and values decorative order. Her care for placing plants between stones shows precision. This highlights her peculiar gardening style.
   

4. What does the sundial in the garden represent? The sundial represents Mrs. Jones’ attempt to include vintage or classic elements. It adds to the decorative theme of the garden. It reflects her sense of what is "nice" or aesthetically pleasing.
   

5. Why does the poet emphasize the small size of the plants? The emphasis on size exaggerates the effort involved in planting them. It builds humor and irony in the poem. It shows the mismatch between effort and impact.

Three-Mark Questions

1. How does the poet use irony in the poem to convey the message? The poet uses irony to highlight the contrast between Mrs. Jones' immense effort and the tiny impact it makes. The act of planting little plants with a pin seems humorous and unnecessary. The garden, being full of stones, hardly benefits from the greenery. Yet, Mrs. Jones treats it like a grand project. The poet gently mocks this tendency to over-decorate rather than embrace natural beauty. This irony makes the reader reflect on what really deserves attention and effort.
   

2. What does Mrs. Jones' garden tell us about her personality and lifestyle? Mrs. Jones' garden reflects a personality that values structure, decoration, and control. Her selection of stone elements and her careful planting routine show her preference for detail. She might be someone who enjoys perfection and is proud of her aesthetic sense. However, this also shows a disconnect from the spontaneity of nature. The garden becomes more of an art project than a living space. Through this, the poet presents her as a symbol of modern, over-managed beauty.
   

3. Why is the setting of the poem important to its overall message? The setting, a stone-filled garden with minimal greenery, is essential to the poem's critique. It emphasizes how human intervention can turn something natural into something artificial. The physical structure of the garden mirrors Mrs. Jones' approach to life—organized, decorative, and perhaps superficial. This allows the poet to explore deeper themes without being direct. The setting becomes a metaphor for people who focus more on appearance than substance. It enriches the poem's satirical tone.
   

4. How does the poet’s tone affect the reader’s understanding of the poem? The poet’s tone is light-hearted and mildly sarcastic, which makes the poem enjoyable yet reflective. Instead of directly criticizing Mrs. Jones, the poet uses humor to highlight her peculiar habits. This tone invites the reader to think without feeling attacked. It softens the critique and makes the commentary more accessible. The reader is entertained while also being encouraged to question certain behaviors. Thus, the tone plays a crucial role in delivering the message.
   

5. What is the significance of the line “plants them with a pin”? This line is an example of hyperbole that emphasizes the small size of the plants. It symbolizes the impracticality of such excessive attention to tiny details. The poet uses this line to critique how some people prioritize appearances over practicality. It paints a vivid picture of Mrs. Jones' obsession with control and perfection. The exaggerated action highlights the central irony of the poem. It reinforces the theme of misplaced effort.

Value-Based Question

What lesson can be learned from the poem A Concrete Example about the way we value appearance over meaning? The poem teaches that people often invest great effort into things that are visually appealing but may lack true purpose or impact. Mrs. Jones' garden represents this tendency to prioritize structure over natural beauty. The poet encourages readers to reflect on whether their efforts are meaningful or just superficial. It’s a reminder that authenticity and balance are more fulfilling than perfection. This message is relevant in both personal and societal contexts, urging us to value substance over show.

End

About BhashaLab

BhashaLab is a dynamic platform dedicated to the exploration and mastery of languages - operating both online and offline. Aligned with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 and the National Credit Framework (NCrF), we offer language education that emphasizes measurable learning outcomes and recognized, transferable credits.

We offer:

1. NEP alligned offline language courses for degree colleges - English, Sanskrit, Marathi and Hindi

2. NEP alligned offline language courses for schools - English, Sanskrit, Marathi and Hindi

3. Std VIII, IX and X - English and Sanskrit Curriculum Tuitions - All boards

4. International English Olympiad Tuitions - All classes

5. Basic and Advanced English Grammar - Offline and Online - Class 3 and above

6. English Communication Skills for working professionals, adults and students - Offline and Online

Contact: +91 86577 20901, +91 97021 12044

Mail: info@bhashalab.com

Website: www.bhashalab.com