1. Freedom - Non-Fiction - Class 12 - Kaleidoscope

BhashaLab
4 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

Author: George Bernard Shaw & J. Krishnamurti

Textbook Name: Kaleidoscope

Genre: Non-fiction (Essay & Philosophical Discourse)

Summary

The chapter “Freedom” is a powerful combination of two thought-provoking essays—one by George Bernard Shaw and the other by J. Krishnamurti. Shaw’s essay critiques the illusion of political and economic freedom in modern societies. He argues that although people are told they are free because they can vote or choose jobs, in reality they are bound by economic systems, societal structures, and unnatural forms of slavery. He contrasts this with natural obligations like eating and sleeping, which are unavoidable yet fulfilling. Shaw exposes how society and governments deceive people into believing they are free while benefiting the ruling class.

Krishnamurti’s section shifts the focus to inner freedom and discipline. He emphasizes that real freedom arises not through external discipline or imposed rules but through inquiry, awareness, and independent thought. He warns against blindly following tradition or authority, which kills sensitivity and intelligence. True freedom, he insists, comes from questioning, discovering, and thinking for oneself, starting from a young age. Both thinkers advocate for meaningful freedom—one grounded in social justice and the other in personal awareness.

Character Sketch (Not applicable — nonfiction essays)

Themes

Theme	Description
Illusion of Freedom	Shaw critiques false notions of democracy and liberty, especially economic freedom.
Natural vs. Social Slavery	Natural needs are fulfilling, while human-imposed slavery is exploitative.
True Discipline vs. Imposed Discipline	Krishnamurti argues that imposed discipline suppresses intelligence and freedom.
Inquiry & Independent Thinking	Krishnamurti emphasizes discovering truth through free inquiry and awareness.
Power Structures	Both authors critique how social and political systems manipulate the masses.
Role of Education	Education should awaken intelligence, not enforce conformity.

✨ Literary / Rhetorical Devices

Device	Example
Rhetorical Questions	“Are you actually so blinded…?” (Krishnamurti)
Irony	Calling wage-slavery “freedom” (Shaw)
Analogy	Natural slavery vs. social slavery
Allusion	References to Magna Carta, Bill of Rights, Waterloo (Shaw)
Repetition	Repeated use of “Freedom” to reinforce the theme
Contrast	Between real and false freedom; natural and artificial compulsion
Personal Address	Use of “you” and “we” to directly involve the reader/listener

Title Justification

The title “Freedom” is apt because both essays deeply explore what true freedom means. Shaw examines freedom in a socio-political and economic context, showing how people are made to believe they are free while actually being controlled by systemic inequalities. Krishnamurti adds a psychological and spiritual dimension, suggesting that freedom is not found in external discipline but in inner awareness and inquiry. The chapter as a whole challenges the superficial definition of freedom and encourages readers to seek real autonomy of mind and life.

One-Mark Questions

What does Shaw mean by 'natural slavery' to Nature?
Shaw refers to natural needs like sleeping, eating, and sheltering that humans must fulfill. He considers these as enjoyable duties, unlike man-made oppressions.
How does Krishnamurti define discipline?
Krishnamurti defines discipline as resistance imposed from outside, which blocks freedom and dulls intelligence.
According to Shaw, what is the role of most governments?Shaw claims most governments enforce slavery under the pretense of freedom. They work to benefit the powerful classes.
What is the difference between natural and unnatural slavery?
Natural slavery results from biological needs and brings pleasure. Unnatural slavery is enforced by society and causes suffering.
Why does Krishnamurti oppose blind obedience?
He believes blind obedience kills sensitivity and stops independent thinking, making one a mechanical follower.

Three-Mark Questions

Explain how Shaw exposes the illusion of freedom in modern democracies.
Shaw argues that though people are told they are free because they vote, they are still economically enslaved. He calls out systems that overwork people and deceive them with false pride in nationalism and history. He critiques governments that serve the wealthy while maintaining social inequality. Shaw uses irony and historical references to highlight how the masses are made to believe in freedom they don’t actually possess. Real freedom, he says, must involve leisure and justice.
How does Krishnamurti differentiate between imposed discipline and true freedom?
Krishnamurti explains that imposed discipline creates fear and conformity. It conditions people to follow rules without thinking, thus killing their sensitivity and intelligence. He stresses that real freedom comes from questioning and discovering truths independently. According to him, education should encourage children to think for themselves rather than simply obeying. True discipline arises naturally when the mind is free and intelligent.
What does Shaw say about the role of education and propaganda in maintaining slavery?
Shaw asserts that from an early age, people are conditioned through education and media to believe they are free. This “mass of humbug,” as he calls it, helps maintain social order by convincing even the privileged classes of its truth. He believes the elite are more deluded than the working classes. Education, instead of awakening, serves to protect the ruling class's interests. Thus, freedom remains an illusion maintained through social conditioning.

Value-Based Question

How can true freedom be achieved according to the views expressed by Shaw and Krishnamurti?

True freedom, as proposed by both Shaw and Krishnamurti, requires more than just legal rights or social claims—it must be rooted in both external justice and internal awareness. Shaw calls for structural changes to reduce social and economic exploitation, giving people more time and resources to live meaningfully. Krishnamurti stresses the importance of questioning, thinking independently, and resisting blind conformity. Together, they emphasize that only when people are both socially empowered and psychologically awakened can freedom be real. This teaches us that freedom is both a right and a responsibility.

End

About BhashaLab:

BhashaLab is a dynamic platform dedicated to the exploration and mastery of languages - operating both online and offline. Aligned with the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 and the National Credit Framework (NCrF), we offer language education that emphasizes measurable learning outcomes and recognized, transferable credits.

We offer:

NEP alligned offline language courses for degree colleges - English, Sanskrit, Marathi and Hindi
NEP alligned offline language courses for schools - English, Sanskrit, Marathi and Hindi
Std VIII, IX and X - English and Sanskrit Curriculum Tuitions - All boards
International English Olympiad Tuitions - All classes
Basic and Advanced English Grammar - Offline and Online - Class 3 and above
English Communication Skills for working professionals, adults and students - Offline and Online